The Ontological Status of Embryos: A Reply to Jason Morris

Published Date: September 13, 2014 | Topics: Philosophy, Religion, Reviews and Commentaries

View Source

[This article was co-authored by Patrick Lee, Christopher Tollefsen, and Robert P. George.]

Abstract

In various places we have defended the position that a new human organism, that is, an individual member of the human species, comes to be at fertilization, the union of the spermatozoon and the oocyte. This individual organism, during the ordinary course of embryological development, remains the same individual and does not undergo any further substantial change, unless monozygotic twinning, or some form of chimerism occurs. Recently, in this Journal Jason Morris has challenged our position, claiming that recent findings in reproductive and stem cell biology have falsified our view. He objects to our claim that a discernible substantial change occurs at conception, giving rise to the existence of a new individual of the human species. In addition, he objects to our claim that the embryo is an individual, a unified whole that persists through various changes, and thus something other than a mere aggregate of cells. Morris raises a number of objections to these claims. However, we will show that his arguments overlook key data and confuse biological, metaphysical, and ethical questions. As a result, his attempts to rebut our arguments fail.

Continue reading in The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine.

More Articles & Essays

Religious Freedom Is About More Than Religion

Published Date: July 25, 2013 | Topics: Civil Rights and Liberties, Religion

U.S. foreign policy should promote liberty of belief—and unbelief. A common theory about freedom of religion suggests that such a value is grounded in a modus vivendi, or compromise: People agree to respect each other’s freedom in order to avoid religiously motivated strife. But the modus vivendi theory obscures the deep ground of principle on […]

Read More

The Wisdom of Upholding Tradition

Published Date: November 20, 2012 | Topics: Natural Law, Politics and Current Affairs

There is a reason why conjugal unions have been distinguished from all others since antiquity. By Sherif Girgis, Ryan T. Anderson and Robert P. George Updated Nov. 20, 2012 8:50 pm ET The U.S. Supreme Court decides next week whether to hear challenges to laws defining marriage as the conjugal union of a man and […]

Read More
View All Articles & Essays