Rubio Can Unhijack ‘Human Rights’
View Source
Secretary of State Marco Rubio has taken swift action against woke Biden-era policies. Passports now list a holder’s sex, not “gender,” and there’s no “X” option; and U.S. embassies are forbidden to display “pride” flags or any other banners than the Stars and Stripes.
These efforts are important and commendable. But Mr. Rubio can do more. He can reinstitute the State Department’s efforts during the first Trump administration to restore the original understanding of human rights. Over the past 30 years, the definition of human rights has been reworked by progressives to promote socially liberal causes and woke dogma.
Human rights have long been a driving moral force in America’s foreign policy. Ronald Reagan made the case against Soviet expansionism and oppression in the language of human rights. The rights to life, religious freedom, freedom of expression, and due process of law are all rooted, as Martin Luther King Jr. observed, in natural law and enshrined in our nation’s founding documents. An understanding of rights as deriving from the inherent and equal dignity of every person echoes the American Founders’ prophetic proclamation “that all men are created equal” and “endowed by their Creator” with “unalienable rights.”
During the Obama and Biden administrations, the State Department reconceived human rights to advance left-wing causes, from castigating countries like Poland for laws that uphold the sanctity of human life in all stages and conditions to funneling foreign aid on behalf of gay rights and transgender ideology.
This reconception of human rights spurred Secretary Mike Pompeo to establish the Commission on Unalienable Rights in 2019, under the chairmanship of Harvard legal scholar Mary Ann Glendon. In its report, the commission outlined the historical Western conception of rights and recommended that the U.S. be “cautious” about “expanding” it.
The effort to stifle “legitimate debate by recasting contestable policy preferences as fixed and unquestionable human rights imperatives,” the commission’s report noted, “promotes intolerance, impedes reconciliation, devalues core rights, and denies rights in the name of rights.”
In his recent speech at the Munich Security Conference, Vice President JD Vance expressed the U.S. government’s concerns about violations of human rights—especially freedom of speech and religion—not only in Russia and China, but even in democracies like Germany, Sweden and the U.K. In bluntly condemning the policing of speech in Germany and thought in the U.K., where people have been arrested for praying silently, Mr. Vance sent a message that protection and promotion of human rights is in the U.S. national interest.
Mr. Rubio ought to revive the report of the Commission on Unalienable Rights and use it as a guidance document to reform human-rights policy. Americans deserve a State Department that defends rights that accord with the constitutional order that our Founders established.