Ontological and Ethical Implications of Direct Nuclear Reprogramming: Response to Magill and Neaves

Published Date: March 11, 2009 | Topics: Philosophy, Reviews and Commentaries

View Source

[This article was co-authored by Maureen L. CondicPatrick Lee, and Robert P. George.]

The paper by Magill and Neaves in this issue of the Journal attempts to rebut the “natural potency” position, based on recent advances in direct reprogramming of somatic cells to yield “induced pluripotent stem” (iPS) cells. As stated by the authors, the natural potency position holds that because “a human embryo directs its own integral organismic function from its beginning . . . there is a whole, albeit immature, and distinct human organism that is intrinsically valuable with the status of inviolability and deserving full moral respect” (p. 26). The authors boldly assert that “The recent production of iPS . . . highlights a prima facie absurdity for the natural potentiality argument” (p. 29). Yet the argument against natural potency is both logically flawed and based on a characterization of the scientific evidence that is factually inaccurate.

Continue reading in the Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal.

More Articles & Essays

Voting for Life

Published Date: October 1, 2020 | Topics: Politics and Current Affairs, Religion

By Ramesh Ponnuru & Robert P. George October 1, 2020 11:19 AM A guide for the perplexed During the vice-presidential debate in 2012, Joe Biden claimed to agree with his church’s teaching on abortion but to be unwilling to impose it on other citizens. It was a statement that depended for its political effectiveness on […]

Read More

Carson the Butler on True Marriage

Published Date: January 8, 2016 | Topics: Natural Law, Philosophy

by Robert P. George 1 . 8 . 16 Viewers of Downton Abbey may have noticed in the recently aired first episode of Season Six that Carson the Butler articulated, in a delicate but firm and unmistakable way, the truth that marriage is a conjugal union. Mrs. Patmore, the cook, is sent as an emissary […]

Read More
View All Articles & Essays