On Peter Simpson on “Illiberal Liberalism”

Published Date: May 10, 2017 | Topics: Philosophy, Politics and Current Affairs, Reviews and Commentaries

View Source

Abstract

Is “liberalism,” as the term is used by leading contemporary self-described liberals such as the late John Rawls and the late Ronald Dworkin, and as put into practice by the contemporary left in western democratic nations, inherently illiberal? Peter Simpson argues cogently that it is. “Anti-perfectionist” or “neutralist” liberalism—liberalism that purports strictly to limit the scope for lawmaking on the basis of what makes for or detracts from a valuable and morally worthy way of life—ends up compromising important and honorable freedoms by absolutizing a radical, and radically partial, conception of freedom itself, one that leaves no room for consideration of the truth concerning these matters or renders their truth irrelevant (or relevant only in highly biased, partial, and tendentious ways) to questions of law and policy related to issues of profound human and moral significance, such as abortion, marriage and sexual morality, and assisted suicide and euthanasia.

Continue reading in The American Journal of Jurisprudence here.

More Articles & Essays

A moral voice

Published Date: December 30, 2020 | Topics: Religion, Reviews and Commentaries

Jewish Review of Books December 30, 2020 A couple of years ago, my wife and I had the honor of having as our house-guests in Princeton Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, of blessed memory, and his wife, Elaine. The morning after their arrival, Rabbi Sacks and I were up early, ahead of our wives, and met […]

Read More

Relativism, conscience, and moral obligation

Published Date: July 12, 2010 | Topics: Philosophy, Religion

By Robert George In June,  I offered some reflections on relativism, conscience, and moral obligation in a commencement address at New St. Andrews College.  In light of our recent discussion on Mirror of Justice, I am posting the core of my remarks below. The witness of Christian colleges and universities is critical to the reform […]

Read More
View All Articles & Essays