Contraception and NFP

Published Date: November 22, 2009 | Topics: Religion

View Source

By Robert George

Natural family planning is not a form of contraception as the Church has always understood it.  In Humanae Vitae, in line with the long tradition of Christian reflection on the subject, Pope Paul VI defined contraception as an action performed before, during, or after an act of sexual intercourse with the intent to render that act of intercourse sterile when it might otherwise be fertile.  NFP does not fit the bill.  It does not represent an attempt to render infertile what one supposes might otherwise be a fertile sexual act. Whatever one’s moral judgment about NFP, it cannot be said to involve the sterilizing of sex acts.  It is true that NFP can be practiced with a “contraceptive mentality.”  That occurs, for example, when someone who would be perfectly willing to contracept chooses periodic abstinence because it is less unpleasant, more convenient, more effective (where reliable contraceptives are not to hand and only unreliable contraceptive techniques are available), or for other such reasons.  I join Michael P. in suggesting that folks who are interested in the question of the morality of contraception and the question of whether NFP is properly understood as “relativizing the procreative norm,” do a bit of reading on the subject.  Michael has recommended Sr. Margaret Farley’s book Just Love: A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics.  I say, by all means, read it.  I would also suggest reading Elizabeth Anscombe’s four essays on contraception (including her classic “Contraception and Chastity”) reprinted in Mary Geach and Luke Gormally (eds.), Faith in a Hard Ground: Essays on Religion, Philosophy and Ethics by G.E.M. Anscombe (Imprint Academic, 2008); John Finnis’s “The Good of Marriage and the Morality of Sexual Relations: Some Philosophical and Historical Observations,” The American Journal of Jurisprudence 42 (1997) 99-134;  and his, “Marriage: a Basic and Exigent Good,”  The Monist 91 (2008); and  Germain Grisez, The Way of the Lord Jesus, vol. 2, Living a Christian Life (Franciscan Press, 1993), chap. 9, together with the pertinent comments by Germain Grisez M. Boyle, Jr. in “Response to Our Critics & Our Collaborators,” in Robert P. George (ed.), Natural Law & Moral Inquiry: Ethics, Metaphysics & Politics in the Work of Germain Grisez (Georgetown UP, 1998).

More Articles & Essays

When Life Begins

Published Date: November 2, 2008 | Topics: Philosophy, Politics and Current Affairs

Will politics trump science? When does the life of a human individual begin? Although the question is of obvious importance for our public policy debates over abortion and embryonic-stem-cell research, politicians have avoided it like the plague. Of late, though, things seem to be changing. Recently some of our nation’s most prominent political leaders, from […]

Read More

Barring Faith

Published Date: July 17, 2006 | Topics: Constitutional Issues, Religion

by Robert George & Gerald Bradley  | July 17, 2006 12:00 AM TO FULLY APPRECIATE the wrong headedness of a federal district court’s recent decision expelling a faith-based program from an Iowa prison, it is necessary first to take a backward glance at the history of religious involvement in corrections in the United States. As […]

Read More
View All Articles & Essays